Consumer Sentiment Falls to 46.3 as Durables Buying Sinks

Consumer sentiment fell to 46.3 in early October, the University of Michigan said Friday, with buying conditions for big-ticket durables plunging.

That lands on the buyer a high-ticket store depends on. For Ecommerce Paradise readers selling furniture, outdoor gear, mobility products and other $1,000-plus items, durables was the weakest line in the survey, and it is the category most of your catalog sits in.

Below you get the numbers with their baselines, why sentiment keeps sliding after the Fed’s September hike, where the spending forecasts disagree with the survey, and five moves to make before the final October reading on Oct. 23. If the model is new to you, start with my guide to high-ticket dropshipping.

Shaky demand is the wrong time to run a store on a sloppy legal foundation, so form your LLC with Northwest, the best LLC formation service for ecommerce owners. Cheap formation sites hook you with a low first-year price and upsell from there, while Northwest Registered Agent keeps the renewal price the same as year one. Form your LLC with Northwest →

Michigan Sentiment Falls to 46.3 as Durables Buying Sinks

The University of Michigan’s preliminary October reading came in at 46.3, down from 48.1 in September and 53.6 in October 2025, according to the survey’s own release. That is a 3.7% drop on the month and 13.6% on the year.

Economists polled by Reuters expected 47.8, per Reuters reporting carried on Yahoo Finance. Another consensus figure circulating before the release was 47.6. Either way, the index missed by more than a full point.

Reuters reports it is the third straight monthly decline, and it sits close to the record low of 44.8 set in May, when the Iran war pushed fuel prices higher, according to Admiral Markets’ preview of the release. Reuters reports the current conditions index fell to 44.7 from 50.9, an all-time low for that measure. The expectations index rose 2.2% to 47.3, per the survey release.

Inflation expectations moved the wrong way too. Year-ahead expectations rose to 4.7% from 4.6%, and five-year expectations rose to 3.5% from 3.4%, both the highest since May, according to the survey. Reuters notes year-ahead expectations stood at 3.4% in February, before the US-Israeli war with Iran began.

The line that matters for you is durables. Survey director Joanne Hsu said buying conditions for durable goods “plummeted amid high prices and borrowing costs.”

How shoppers say they will respond

Reuters reports that just under a third of consumers expect to keep spending as usual on items with large price increases. About 54% plan to cut back, and roughly 16% say they will stop buying those items altogether.

The damage is uneven. Sentiment fell steeply among lower-income consumers and those with smaller stock portfolios, per the survey, and Reuters says higher-income households are driving consumer spending in what it calls a K-shaped economy. Reuters also described September payroll gains as underwhelming.

The political split matters less than the income split, but it is there. Reuters reports sentiment among Democrats and Republicans ticked up from September yet stayed well below January levels, while Independents declined. In other words, no single customer segment is rescuing the number.

Jim Baird, chief investment officer at Plante Moran Financial Advisors, told Reuters that “consumers across the political spectrum are frustrated with rising prices and a sense of treading water financially.” The final October reading is scheduled for Friday, Oct. 23 at 10 a.m. ET, per the survey.

Sentiment Sits Near May’s Low After a September Fed Hike

The Fed raised its target range by 25 basis points to 3.75% to 4% on Sept. 16, a unanimous 12-0 vote and the first hike since 2023, according to Schwab’s FOMC coverage. The statement said “inflation remains elevated.”

The minutes, released Oct. 7, showed that most participants judged a further increase “would likely be appropriate by year end,” per investingLive’s summary of the minutes. Officials said progress on inflation had stalled, and staff estimated August headline PCE inflation at 3.8% and core at 3.4%, with 2% not reached until 2029.

Consumers have been feeling that for weeks. I covered the Conference Board’s September reading, which fell to 81.9 from 88.6, in my breakdown of consumer confidence falling as the Fed hiked. The Michigan index slid from 51.7 in August to 48.1 in September in the same coverage, so October extends a trend rather than starting one.

Borrowing costs are the transmission line. My note on the 24-year Treasury yield high covers what it does to credit lines. A follow-up on a weak jobs report cutting October hike odds shows the market is still arguing about how much more is coming.

The counterpoint: spending forecasts are still up

Sentiment and spending do not always move together, and this year’s holiday forecasts say so. Adobe projects $275.1 billion in US online holiday sales for Nov. 1 to Dec. 31, up 6.7% from last year. Adobe’s furniture forecast is $33.4 billion, up 7.3%, and buy now, pay later is $21.3 billion, up 6.6%.

The ICSC holiday survey I covered found nearly half of shoppers expect to borrow, which is the same pressure seen from a different angle, in my post on holiday shoppers planning to borrow. ICSC projects retail sales growth of 4.3% to 4.9%.

Adobe released its forecast in late September, before this reading, so it does not capture the October drop. James Knightley, chief international economist at ING, told Reuters the picture changes quickly if stocks correct: “if we were to experience a stock market correction, then the situation would change quickly.” Surveys also measure attitudes, and what people say in a poll is not the same as what they put in a cart.

What 46.3 Means for a High-Ticket Store’s Holiday Quarter

My read: this is a mix problem, not a collapse. The Michigan data and the Adobe forecast can both be right if affluent buyers carry the quarter while middle-income buyers who finance a purchase hold back. High-ticket stores sell to both groups, and the second group is the one that converts on a monthly payment.

Hsu’s durables line maps straight onto a $2,000 to $10,000 order. A buyer who is weighing a $3,000 purchase against a card APR near 21%, or a bank loan that just got more expensive, waits. In ad terms, you do not lose the click. You lose the close two weeks later.

Rough math, clearly hypothetical

Take a hypothetical store doing 40 orders a month at a $3,000 average order, or $120,000 in revenue. Say gross margin is 20%, which is $24,000 a month. If the sentiment drag cuts closed orders by 10%, that is four orders, $12,000 in revenue, and $2,400 in gross profit gone. The ad bill does not shrink on its own, so net margin takes the hit.

Now add the card side. If ad spend sits on a card with an APR near 21%, every month a balance rolls costs you real money. The Credit Card Competition Act, which I covered in Trump backing the bill, targets swipe fees rather than the APR on your own card. The numbers above are an illustration, not a forecast for your store.

Three scenarios and the thresholds I would watch

These thresholds are my own rules of thumb, not published guidance. First scenario: the final Oct. 23 reading lands between 45 and 48. I would treat that as a soft patch, keep branded and high-intent spend running, and trim cold prospecting that has not closed.

Second scenario: the final reading prints below May’s 44.8 record low. That is a new regime, and I would cut spend that does not return its cost within the same week and push every product page toward a financing offer. Third scenario: a stock correction. Reuters says wealthier households are the ones holding spending up, and ING’s Knightley warns a correction would change that fast, so the K-shape could break and hit the buyers you thought were safe.

Pricing without a discount war

Adobe expects furniture discounts to peak around 18%, slightly shallower than last year’s 19%. If you sell on MAP pricing, you cannot match a deep markdown anyway, and I would not try. Financing is a cleaner lever: Wayfair put 0% APR for six months on the table, which I broke down in Wayfair expanding Klarna, and the same logic applies to your checkout.

Affordability is also becoming an AI checkout feature, per my report on BNPL entering AI checkout. A store that shows a monthly price on the product page is easier for both a human and an agent to recommend.

What a hesitant high-ticket buyer actually does

A buyer who is spooked by prices rarely vanishes. They slow down. The ICSC holiday survey I covered found 86% of shoppers plan additional research before buying, and 58% are willing to try a new brand. Those are people comparing you against two or three other tabs, not people who have left.

That changes where I would put effort. A hesitant buyer closes on trust and follow-up, so your phone number belongs on every page, your reviews need to be current, and your shipping and return terms need to be impossible to misread. Owned email is the cheapest way to stay in front of that buyer, and Klaviyo handles the quote and cart flows well. I walked through the flows every store should run in my guide to ecommerce email marketing flows.

Dropshipping also gives you a structural edge in a soft quarter. You do not hold inventory, so a slow November does not leave you with stock you paid for and cannot move. Your real fixed costs are ads, software and people, which is why the margin check in the action list below comes before any new spend. Ask your suppliers now whether they plan holiday promotions or rebates, because a supplier-funded offer protects your margin in a way a self-funded discount does not.

When demand softens, store owners who do everything themselves tend to burn out on support, follow-up and ads at the same time. That is the problem the turnkey done-for-you service solves for people who want the store running without living in it. I am not a financial advisor, and none of this is personal financial advice.

Sentiment at 46.3 means conversion is the first number to slip. Want my team to scale the store you already have, with the ad and follow-up work handled? See the scaling service →

Five Moves Before the Oct. 23 Final Sentiment Reading

Do these in order. Each takes an afternoon or less.

Put a monthly payment price on every product over $1,000 in Shopify, and make sure the financing option shows on the product page, not only at checkout. Adobe’s $21.3 billion BNPL forecast says buyers are using it.
Rebuild your abandoned-cart and quote-request flows so the second and third emails address price and payment, not just “you left something behind.” Send the first within an hour.
Pull your real margin by order. A bookkeeping tool such as Finaloop shows profit per order. QuickBooks works if your accountant already lives there. If a 10% order drop turns a month negative, you need to know before Black Friday.
Cut cold prospecting that has not produced a closed order in 30 days, and run an incrementality test on the rest. Google’s new conversion lift tests for Search and PMax are built for exactly that question.
Check credit line headroom and cash on hand before the Fed meets Oct. 27 and 28, the date I flagged in my consumer confidence post. Review which business card carries your ad spend using my business credit card picks. Then decide where idle cash should sit, for example in a brokerage account at Schwab.

Two notes on pacing. Do not wait for the Oct. 23 print to act on items one through three, because they cost almost nothing and help in every scenario. Items four and five depend on how the next two data points land, so set a calendar reminder for both dates and decide the spend question the same day. If you want a second set of eyes on your numbers first, book a discovery call.

For the support load, a part-time hire from OnlineJobs.ph costs far less than a missed follow-up. Gorgias keeps pre-sale questions from sitting in an inbox. The shoppers who ask about financing are the ones who buy.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the University of Michigan consumer sentiment index?
It is a monthly survey of US households on their finances and the economy. The preliminary October reading was 46.3, per the survey’s release.

Does low sentiment mean my sales will fall?
Not automatically. Adobe still forecasts record online holiday sales, but Reuters reports the strength comes from higher-income households. My earlier post on Prime Big Deal Days spending showed $9.86 billion in sales with only 2% of items above $100, which suggests big-ticket buyers are choosier.

When is the next reading?
The final October Michigan data comes Oct. 23 at 10 a.m. ET, and the next Fed meeting is Oct. 27 and 28.

Should I cut my ad budget?
Trim what is not closing, but do not starve high-intent campaigns. My breakdown of Google Ads budget and quality explains why budget pacing affects results.

Which niches hold up when sentiment drops?
The survey does not say. My opinion is that replacement purchases and needs-based products hold up better than discretionary ones. Browse the high-ticket niches list first. My free niches list goes further.

How does the Fed hike hit a small store?
Through card APRs, line-of-credit rates and your customers’ financing costs. Hsu cited high prices and borrowing costs for the durables plunge.

Slow demand exposes a weak offer fast. Want 1-on-1 coaching to fix your high-ticket store before holiday traffic arrives? Get the coaching details →

I will keep tracking the Oct. 23 reading and the Fed meeting right after it. Subscribe to the YouTube channel for daily breakdowns. More breaking news coming through the day.

If this was useful, these go deeper:

Trevor Fenner

Trevor Fenner is an ecommerce entrepreneur and the founder of Ecommerce Paradise, a platform focused on helping entrepreneurs build and scale profitable high-ticket ecommerce and dropshipping businesses. With over a decade of hands-on experience, Trevor specializes in high-ticket dropshipping strategy, niche and product selection, supplier recruiting and onboarding, Google & Bing Shopping ads, ecommerce SEO, and systems-driven automation and scaling. Through Ecommerce Paradise, he provides free education via in-depth guides like How to Start High-Ticket Dropshipping, advanced training through the High-Ticket Dropshipping Masterclass, and fully done-for-you turnkey ecommerce services for entrepreneurs who want a faster, more hands-off path to growth. Trevor is known for emphasizing sustainable, real-world ecommerce models over hype-driven tactics, helping store owners build scalable, sellable, and location-independent brands.