Over five years, ExpressVPN costs $176.61 more than CyberGhost. Both services encrypt your traffic, both have apps on everything, and neither will feel different on a normal day.
So the question is not which is better. It is whether $176.61 buys you something you will actually use, and the honest answer depends on one thing: whether your business breaks when a VPN fails.
I run Ecommerce Paradise from overseas, which means a VPN is how I reach US supplier portals and my own bank rather than a privacy preference. I have paid the ExpressVPN premium historically and I want to be straight about why, and about the cases where it is a waste of money. Both checkout pages were read on 15 September 2026, from the raw markup rather than the marketing, with first-term and renewal prices kept apart the whole way down.
$51.74 a Year Against $99.95 a Year
Both renewal figures are published. That is the comparison that decides this, and almost nobody makes it.
The Numbers, Side by Side
These came off CyberGhost’s buy page on the morning of 15 September. The ExpressVPN figures were read the same morning from its own order page.
| CyberGhost | ExpressVPN Basic | |
|---|---|---|
| Advertised rate | $1.99/mo | $2.99/mo |
| You pay today | $51.74 | $83.72 |
| Term | 26 months | 28 months |
| Annual renewal | $51.74 | $99.95 |
| Renewal per month | $4.31 | $8.33 |
| Rate increase at renewal | 117 percent | 179 percent |
| Simultaneous devices | 7 | 10 |
| Money-back window | 45 days | 30 days |
| Monthly plan | $12.99 | Not led with |
Both publish their renewal, which puts this pair ahead of a lot of the category. ExpressVPN prints it in the same block as the offer. CyberGhost prints it on the card. Neither is hiding anything, and that alone makes this a comparison you can actually do.
What the Gap Looks Like Over Time
One year of either service is not a meaningful comparison, because the first bill covers more than two years. Model the period you will realistically hold it.
| Holding period | CyberGhost | ExpressVPN Basic | Difference |
|---|---|---|---|
| First term only | $51.74 / 26 months | $83.72 / 28 months | $31.98 |
| Plus one renewal | $103.48 / 38 months | $183.67 / 40 months | $80.19 |
| Plus two renewals | $155.22 / 50 months | $283.62 / 52 months | $128.40 |
| Plus three renewals | $206.96 / 62 months | $383.57 / 64 months | $176.61 |
Average cost per month across that full period is $3.34 for CyberGhost and $5.99 for ExpressVPN. Neither is expensive in absolute terms. The gap simply compounds, because the renewal rates differ by more than the headline rates do.
Notice what happens to the difference column. It starts at $31.98 and more than quintuples by year five. Comparing these two on the advertised rate understates the real gap by a factor of five.
The Discount Badges Are Built the Same Way
Worth knowing before you weigh a “save 80%” against a “save 85%”, because the two numbers are not measuring what you would assume.
ExpressVPN strikes through $419.72 as the regular price of Basic. Divide it by the 28-month term and you get $14.99, which is its month-to-month rate. The struck figure is 28 individual months bought one at a time, not a 28-month plan anyone was ever offered.
CyberGhost’s badge works identically. Its monthly plan is $12.99, and across 26 months that is $337.74. Charging $51.74 against that total is the 85 percent.
| Service | Monthly rate | Term | Implied “regular price” | Actual price | Badge |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| CyberGhost | $12.99 | 26 months | $337.74 | $51.74 | Save 85% |
| ExpressVPN Basic | $14.99 | 28 months | $419.72 | $83.72 | Save 80% |
Both are honest arithmetic against a baseline nobody buys. The practical takeaway is that a bigger badge does not mean a better deal, it mostly means a more expensive monthly plan to measure against.
What ExpressVPN Actually Buys
The case for paying nearly double on renewal is not features, and anyone selling it to you on features is reaching. It is reliability, and that is a harder thing to demonstrate in a table.
What is concrete: Basic covers 10 devices against CyberGhost’s 7, advertises speeds up to 40 Gbps, includes Lite Protection that blocks ads, malicious sites and adult sites, and bundles ExpressMailGuard with 10 MB a month of private email relay and 10 shared aliases. A dedicated IP is available as a paid add-on.
The tiers above Basic add device count and protection scope rather than a better VPN.
| ExpressVPN tier | Rate | Paid today | Annual renewal | Devices |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Basic | $2.99/mo | $83.72 | $99.95 | 10 |
| Advanced | $3.99/mo | $111.72 | $119.95 | 12 |
| Pro | $5.99/mo | $167.72 | $199.95 | 14 |
Advanced is the interesting one on renewal maths. It costs $1.00 a month more than Basic in the first term but only $1.67 a month more at renewal, because Basic climbs 179 percent while Advanced climbs 151 percent. Pro climbs 178 percent, so the middle tier is the outlier rather than the entry tier. What does hold in order across all three is the discount depth: 80 percent off Basic, 76 percent off Advanced, 74 percent off Pro. The cheapest headline carries the deepest discount, and a deep discount is what a steep renewal looks like on the way in.
The full ladder including the struck-through figures is in the ExpressVPN pricing breakdown.
Running the Store From Overseas?
A VPN is one line item. Suppliers, entity, store and launch are the other four. We build all of it with you.
What CyberGhost Actually Buys
The obvious answer is the lower price, but that is the least interesting part.
The 45-day money-back window is the longest in the mainstream category and ExpressVPN gives 30. Six and a half weeks is enough to run a full business cycle through a VPN, including a month end and whatever your suppliers send you in that time. Thirty days is enough to confirm it works today.
The renewal is also flatter. CyberGhost raises your rate once and then charges the same $51.74 every year afterwards. That is worth more than it sounds when you are budgeting software across a few years.
There is one more thing buried in CyberGhost’s own page data. It defines a 12-month plan at $4.15 a month that the US layout does not display, and that figure sits within 16 cents of the $4.31 renewal rate. In other words, CyberGhost’s renewal is roughly what it charges with no promotion attached. ExpressVPN’s renewal of $8.33 a month sits well below its $14.99 monthly rate but well above anything it advertises, which is a different pricing philosophy.
The remaining CyberGhost plans are a 6-month at $6.99 a month renewing at $41.94 every six months, and a monthly at $12.99 renewing at $12.99. Both renew flat, unlike the long plan.
Where This Pair Sits in the Wider Category
Useful context, because ExpressVPN is often described as the expensive option and CyberGhost as the cheap one. On renewal, neither of those labels holds up.
| Service | Advertised | Annual renewal | Renewal per month |
|---|---|---|---|
| PureVPN Standard | $2.15/mo | $47.95 | $4.00 |
| CyberGhost | $1.99/mo | $51.74 | $4.31 |
| ExpressVPN Basic | $2.99/mo | $99.95 | $8.33 |
| NordVPN Basic | $3.49/mo | $139.08 | $11.59 |
ExpressVPN is not the most expensive service in this category. NordVPN renews 39 percent higher, at $139.08 a year against ExpressVPN’s $99.95. And CyberGhost is not the cheapest, because PureVPN Standard renews at $47.95.
So the real ordering on long-run cost is PureVPN, then CyberGhost, then ExpressVPN, then NordVPN, and the two names most people have heard of are the two at the expensive end.
The Honest Case for Paying More
I want to make this argument properly rather than dismiss it, because I have made the purchase myself.
If you are operating a store from outside the United States, your VPN is not a privacy tool. It is the thing standing between you and your supplier’s dealer portal, your payment processor’s dashboard, and your business bank. When it fails, you are not mildly inconvenienced, you are locked out of your own company for the afternoon.
In that situation the variable you care about is not price, it is how often the service is the reason something did not work. A VPN that costs $4 a month more and fails half as often is not a close call, and $176.61 over five years is less than a single lost day.
The failure that costs you is not a slow connection. It is a supplier portal that flags the IP, a bank that locks the login, or a service that stops working in your country for a week with no explanation. Those are the events you are insuring against.
But that argument only holds if the premise is true. If you are in the US, working from your own office, and you bought a VPN because you read that you should, none of the above applies to you. You are paying an insurance premium on a risk you do not carry.
What a Failure Actually Looks Like
The reliability argument gets waved around in every VPN comparison without anyone saying what they mean, so here is what actually goes wrong in practice.
It is almost never speed. A supplier portal loading in 3 seconds instead of 1 has never cost anybody an order. The failures that matter are binary.
The first is a shared IP that a service has flagged. Budget VPNs pack more customers onto each address, so the odds that somebody before you triggered a fraud rule on your payment processor go up. You do not see an error explaining this. You see a login that silently will not complete.
The second is a bank that treats the connection as suspicious. Business banking security is tuned to flag logins from data centre addresses, and once your account is locked you are on the phone during business hours in a timezone you do not live in.
The third is a country-level block that lands overnight. Services get blocked in specific regions with no notice and no fix on your end, and you find out when you cannot work.
Both services sell a dedicated IP add-on precisely because of the first problem. CyberGhost charges $5.00 a month for it, which is two and a half times the VPN itself on the long plan and takes your effective rate to $6.99. ExpressVPN offers it as an add-on on Basic and includes it on Pro.
That is worth noticing, because a CyberGhost plan with a dedicated IP costs $6.99 a month against ExpressVPN Basic at $2.99. If the shared-address problem is the one you actually have, the cheap option stops being cheap.
Buying for a Short Trip
One case where both long plans are the wrong purchase, and where the two diverge in a way rarely mentioned.
If you are away for a month and want a VPN only while travelling, the monthly plan is correct and the 26-month commitment is not. CyberGhost publishes a monthly plan at $12.99 that renews at $12.99, with a 14-day refund window rather than 45.
ExpressVPN leads its order page entirely with 2-year plans. A month-to-month option exists, and the struck-through $419.72 across 28 months tells you it runs $14.99, but the page is not built to sell it to you.
So for a two-month trip you are weighing $25.98 on CyberGhost against roughly $29.98 on ExpressVPN, and the gap that looks enormous across five years shrinks to $4.00 across two months.
The version of this that costs real money is buying 26 months to save $11.00 a month on a need that will not last 26 months. Two expensive months still cost less than 26 cheap ones.
Cost Per Device
Since the device counts differ, it is worth expressing both in the unit that varies.
| Devices covered | CyberGhost, per device per year | ExpressVPN Basic, per device per year |
|---|---|---|
| 3 | $7.96 | $11.96 |
| 7 | $3.41 | $5.13 |
| 10 | $4.78, two subscriptions | $3.59 |
Those are first-term figures based on $23.88 a year for CyberGhost and $35.88 for ExpressVPN. The result at 10 devices is the one that surprised me. ExpressVPN is cheaper per device there, at $3.59 against $4.78, because CyberGhost needs a second subscription to reach 10 while ExpressVPN covers it on one.
So the price gap is real below 8 devices and inverts above 7. If you are covering a partner and an assistant as well as yourself, run the arithmetic before assuming the cheaper headline wins.
How to Decide Without Guessing
There is a way to settle this that costs you nothing, and it beats reading any comparison article including this one.
Buy CyberGhost first. It is cheaper, and its 45-day window is 15 days longer than ExpressVPN’s. Spend the first two weeks putting it through the exact things you need it for. Log into your business bank. Open every supplier portal you use. Load the payment processor dashboard. Use it as your default, not as a test.
If everything works, you are done and you have saved $176.61 over five years. If something specific fails, you now know precisely what ExpressVPN needs to solve, and you claim the CyberGhost refund inside a window you have barely dented.
The order matters. Testing the cheaper service first with the longer window costs you nothing and answers the question with evidence rather than reputation.
One warning on the mechanics. Refund windows in this category run from the purchase date rather than from first use, so buying in advance and installing three weeks later burns most of your protection for nothing. Buy when you are ready to test.
Which One I Would Buy
CyberGhost, for most people reading this. Seven devices covers a solo operator comfortably, the renewal is published and flat, and the 45-day window means you find out for certain before the money is committed.
ExpressVPN, if access is genuinely load-bearing. If you cannot run your business without reaching US-only systems from abroad every day, buy the reliability and stop optimising a $4 line item.
ExpressVPN, if a cheaper service has already failed you. The cost of a VPN that dies during a supplier call is not measured in subscription dollars, and if you have lived through it once you already know which column you are in.
Neither, if you need more than 14 devices. CyberGhost caps at 7 and even ExpressVPN Pro stops at 14, so that is a different shortlist, and the CyberGhost alternatives comparison covers the services that solve it.
Whatever you pick, the strategy is one line long. Buy the long term, then set a calendar reminder two months before it ends. Both of these companies publish what the renewal will be, which means there is no excuse for being surprised by it.
Where a VPN Fits in the Build Order
Worth saying, because this is a tool people buy early for reasons that do not survive questioning.
A VPN solves an access problem, not a business problem. If you are outside the United States and need to reach supplier portals, payment processors or your own bank, it is required infrastructure and belongs on the first invoice you pay. That is my situation and it is why I have never been without one.
If you are in the US and simply read that VPNs are good practice, either of these buys a habit that changes nothing about whether your store works. The attention is better spent on deciding what you sell, which the high-ticket niches list covers at no cost.
Supplier approval is the real constraint on this business and none of it turns on which VPN you picked. The process is laid out in the supplier outreach guide.
Distributors want a registered entity before they will discuss terms, which the business formation guide walks through. If the model itself is still the open question, read what high-ticket dropshipping actually is before buying any software at all.
Test the Cheaper One First, With 45 Days to Change Your Mind
Every CyberGhost plan, the published renewal, and the three products it does not show on screen.
Common Questions
Is CyberGhost cheaper than ExpressVPN?
Yes, on both numbers. You pay $51.74 for 26 months against $83.72 for 28, and CyberGhost renews at $51.74 a year against ExpressVPN’s $99.95. Across about five years the difference is $176.61.
Is ExpressVPN worth nearly double on renewal?
Only if reaching US-only services from abroad is load-bearing for your business. In that case reliability is the product and $4 a month is the wrong variable to optimise. For occasional public wifi use, no.
How many devices does each cover?
CyberGhost allows 7 simultaneous connections on every plan. ExpressVPN allows 10 on Basic, 12 on Advanced and 14 on Pro. If you need more than 14, neither of these is the right answer.
Which has the better money-back guarantee?
CyberGhost, at 45 days on its long and 6-month plans against ExpressVPN’s 30 days. CyberGhost’s monthly plan is the exception at 14 days.
Do both publish their renewal prices?
Yes, and it is worth crediting them for it. ExpressVPN prints the renewal in the same block as the offer. CyberGhost prints it on the plan card. Several competitors publish no renewal figure at all.
Which ExpressVPN tier should I pick if I go that way?
Basic for most people. Advanced costs $1.00 a month more in the first term but only $1.67 more at renewal, so if you expect to keep it for years the gap narrows considerably. Pro is worth it only for the higher device count or the included dedicated IP.
Related Articles
- CyberGhost Pricing 2026: Why $51.74 Twice Is a 117% Increase
- ExpressVPN Pricing 2026: The $2.99 Is a 28-Month Price
- CyberGhost Alternatives 2026: Ranked by Renewal Price, Not Headline
- ExpressVPN Alternatives 2026: It Is Not the Expensive One Anymore
- CyberGhost VPN Review 2026: A Budget VPN With a Genuinely Long Money-Back Window
Trevor Fenner is an ecommerce entrepreneur and the founder of Ecommerce Paradise, a platform focused on helping entrepreneurs build and scale profitable high-ticket ecommerce and dropshipping businesses. With over a decade of hands-on experience, Trevor specializes in high-ticket dropshipping strategy, niche and product selection, supplier recruiting and onboarding, Google & Bing Shopping ads, ecommerce SEO, and systems-driven automation and scaling. Through Ecommerce Paradise, he provides free education via in-depth guides like How to Start High-Ticket Dropshipping, advanced training through the High-Ticket Dropshipping Masterclass, and fully done-for-you turnkey ecommerce services for entrepreneurs who want a faster, more hands-off path to growth. Trevor is known for emphasizing sustainable, real-world ecommerce models over hype-driven tactics, helping store owners build scalable, sellable, and location-independent brands.
Still deciding what to sell?
Grab the free list of 1,000+ niches that work for high-ticket dropshipping, sorted by category.
Free. Unsubscribe any time.
