I recommend Amazon Prime to most people in the Ecommerce Paradise community who ask me about it, but it isn’t automatically the right membership for every shopper, and a few competitors have closed the gap considerably over the past couple of years. This guide compares the real alternatives worth considering if you’re weighing Prime against Walmart+, Costco, Sam’s Club, or Target Circle 360.
If you’re building a high-ticket dropshipping business or any kind of ecommerce operation on the side, this decision is worth more thought than it gets credit for, since a lot of these memberships double as useful research and shipping tools once you look past the consumer marketing.
| Program | Price | Best For |
|---|---|---|
| Amazon Prime | $14.99/mo or $139/yr | Broadest catalog, fastest ecommerce shipping |
| Walmart+ | $12.95/mo or $98/yr | Grocery delivery, gas savings, streaming choice |
| Costco Membership | $65/yr (Gold Star) | Bulk buying, warehouse prices, no shipping focus |
| Sam’s Club Plus | $110/yr | Bulk buying with free shipping and early hours |
| Target Circle 360 | $10.99/mo or $99/yr | Free same-day delivery from Target stores |
Walmart+: The Closest Direct Competitor
Walmart+ is priced at $12.95 a month or $98 a year, meaningfully cheaper than Prime’s $139 annual rate, and it competes hardest on grocery delivery and fuel savings rather than general ecommerce shipping. Members get free same-day grocery and pharmacy delivery on orders over $35, free shipping with no order minimum on Walmart.com, 10 cents off per gallon at participating gas stations, and a choice between Paramount+ or Peacock streaming at no extra cost.
Where Walmart+ falls short of Prime is catalog breadth and shipping speed on general merchandise. Walmart’s online marketplace has grown substantially, but it still doesn’t match Amazon’s selection or the reliability of Prime’s 1-2 day delivery window across as wide a range of product categories. Walmart+ also offers a reduced Walmart+ Assist rate of $6.47 a month or $49 a year for qualifying government-assistance recipients and students, mirroring Amazon’s own discounted tiers.
Costco Membership: Warehouse Savings Over Shipping Speed
A Costco Gold Star membership runs about $65 a year, and the entire value proposition is fundamentally different from Prime. Costco isn’t trying to compete on shipping speed at all, the savings come from buying in bulk at warehouse prices, which works out significantly cheaper per unit on groceries, household staples, and certain electronics than shopping at standard retail, Amazon included.
The tradeoff is that Costco requires an in-person warehouse visit for most of its best pricing, though its online ordering has expanded. There’s no equivalent to Prime Video, Prime Gaming, or free two-day shipping on a broad catalog. Costco makes sense as a complement to Prime rather than a replacement for anyone who values fast home delivery, not just bulk savings on a grocery run.
Sam’s Club Plus: Walmart’s Bulk-Buying Answer to Costco
Sam’s Club offers two membership tiers: a base Club membership around $60 a year, and Plus membership at roughly $110 a year, which adds free shipping on orders over $50, 2% cash back on most purchases, early shopping hours, and additional pharmacy and optical savings. Like Costco, Sam’s Club’s core appeal is bulk warehouse pricing rather than fast ecommerce shipping.
Sam’s Club Plus members do get more shipping-adjacent perks than a standard Costco membership, since Walmart owns Sam’s Club and has pushed harder on integrating it with Walmart’s broader delivery infrastructure. Still, neither Sam’s Club tier replaces Prime’s catalog breadth or 1-2 day delivery speed on general merchandise outside the warehouse model.
Target Circle 360: Free Same-Day Delivery Focus
Target Circle 360 costs $10.99 a month or $99 a year, with a discounted rate of $4.99 a month or $49 a year for verified teachers, military members, college students, and Target Circle Card holders. The core benefit is free same-day delivery on eligible orders through Target’s Shipt-powered delivery network, plus free two-day shipping and an extended 30-day return window on most purchases.
Target Circle 360 makes the most sense for shoppers who already do a large share of their household shopping at Target and want delivery speed without leaving that ecosystem. It doesn’t include a streaming perk, gaming benefit, or anything resembling Prime’s entertainment stack, the membership is scoped narrowly around shopping and delivery rather than trying to be an all-in-one lifestyle bundle.
Which Alternative Fits Which Shopper
If grocery delivery and gas savings matter more to you than broad ecommerce shipping, Walmart+ at $98 a year is the strongest value alternative to Prime. If you’re mainly trying to cut per-unit costs on household staples and don’t mind an in-person warehouse trip, Costco or Sam’s Club will save more money over a year than any shipping-focused membership possibly could.
If Target is already where you do most of your shopping and same-day delivery from a nearby store matters more than Amazon’s catalog size, Target Circle 360 is worth the $99 annual price. None of these alternatives fully replicate Prime’s combination of catalog breadth, shipping speed, and entertainment perks in a single membership, which is exactly why Prime remains the default recommendation for most online shoppers.
Stacking Multiple Memberships
A meaningful share of active shoppers end up holding two memberships rather than picking one exclusively, commonly Prime plus Costco, since the two serve genuinely different purposes rather than directly overlapping. Prime covers fast shipping and entertainment, while Costco or Sam’s Club covers bulk grocery and household savings that neither Amazon nor Walmart can fully match at the same per-unit price.
Before stacking two paid memberships, it’s worth actually running the math on your own shopping habits rather than assuming more memberships automatically means more savings. Two subscriptions you use heavily will outperform one you use occasionally, but two subscriptions you barely touch is just money left on the table either way.
What None of These Alternatives Fully Replace
None of Prime’s direct competitors currently match its combination of Prime Video, Prime Gaming, Prime Reading, and free Grubhub+ delivery bundled into one membership fee. Walmart+’s streaming choice comes closest, offering a single ad-supported service, but it’s a narrower entertainment stack than Prime’s, and none of the warehouse club memberships include any streaming benefit at all.
If entertainment perks are a meaningful part of why you value Prime, switching to any of these alternatives means either giving up that stack entirely or paying separately for streaming services you’d otherwise get bundled in.
For Ecommerce Sellers Comparing Research and Fulfillment Perks
If you’re using a shopping membership partly as a research tool for product sourcing and niche research, Amazon’s catalog breadth and fast shipping still make it the most useful option for ordering competitor products and checking real customer reviews quickly. Walmart+ and Target Circle 360 both work reasonably well for the same purpose within their respective catalogs, though neither matches Amazon’s overall product selection.
Costco and Sam’s Club are less useful for this kind of rapid competitive research, since their catalogs are narrower and built around bulk household goods rather than the wide range of niche products you’d typically be evaluating while vetting suppliers for a new store.
Business Considerations When Choosing Between Memberships
If any of these memberships are being used partly for business purposes, ordering packaging, testing products, or sourcing supplies, the membership fee may be a deductible business expense depending on how you use it and how your business formation is structured. This applies equally to Prime, Walmart+, Costco, Sam’s Club, and Target Circle 360, so it’s worth raising with your accountant regardless of which membership you end up choosing.
Some operators keep separate business and personal memberships entirely to keep expense tracking clean, which becomes more manageable the more clearly you’ve separated business and personal finances from the start.
Switching Costs and Timing Your Move
None of these memberships lock you in beyond the current billing period, and most offer free trials that make testing an alternative low-risk before committing to a full year. The smartest way to switch is to let your current Prime membership run out naturally rather than canceling mid-cycle, then trial the alternative during Prime’s off period to see whether the tradeoffs actually work for how you shop.
Keep in mind that switching away from Prime means losing any Prime-specific perks tied to other Amazon services, including Prime Day access and Kindle Unlimited bundling offers, so it’s worth weighing those alongside the core shipping and pricing comparison before making a final call. Running a short overlap period where you keep both memberships active for a month is often the most reliable way to make a genuinely informed decision rather than switching cold based on price alone.
What Independent Comparisons Say
Kiplinger’s side-by-side comparison of Walmart+ and Amazon Prime found that Walmart+ tends to win on grocery-focused value for households that shop in-store or order groceries frequently, while Prime wins decisively on general merchandise selection and delivery speed options for anyone ordering a wide variety of products. That split lines up closely with how I’d frame the decision for most online shoppers weighing the two.
The Motley Fool’s breakdown of Prime versus Costco reaches a similar conclusion for warehouse clubs: Costco wins clearly on per-unit savings for bulk household staples, but it simply isn’t built to compete with Prime’s shipping speed or catalog breadth, since the two memberships are solving fundamentally different shopping problems rather than competing head-to-head on the same benefit.
How Return Policies Compare Across These Memberships
Return policy is an underrated factor when comparing these memberships, since it directly affects how comfortable you’ll feel ordering something you haven’t seen in person. Amazon’s standard 30-day return window applies broadly across most Prime-eligible purchases, with free return shipping in most cases and drop-off options at partner locations.
Target Circle 360 extends the standard 90-day Target return window by an extra 30 days for members, giving online shoppers meaningfully more flexibility than the standard policy. Walmart’s return window varies more by product category, while Costco and Sam’s Club are known for unusually generous, sometimes open-ended return policies on many categories, which is part of what makes warehouse memberships appealing for higher-cost purchases you want backed by a strong guarantee.
Customer Service and Support Differences
Amazon’s customer service is available 24/7 through chat and phone, and Prime members generally get faster response prioritization than non-member accounts. Walmart and Target both offer solid support during business hours with growing chat-based options, though neither currently matches Amazon’s around-the-clock availability at the same scale.
Costco and Sam’s Club lean more heavily on in-person support at the membership desk for anything beyond a simple online order issue, which some members actually prefer for resolving problems quickly, while others find less convenient than a fully remote support experience.
Delivery Coverage and Rural Availability
Coverage is one of the biggest practical differences between these memberships once you get outside a major metro area. CNBC Select’s comparison of Prime and Walmart+ delivery options notes that Amazon’s logistics network still reaches more rural zip codes with consistent shipping than Walmart+’s same-day grocery delivery, which is concentrated more heavily around metro and suburban areas near Walmart supercenters.
Target Circle 360’s same-day delivery through Shipt faces a similar coverage gap in rural areas, since it depends on gig-economy drivers operating within a set radius of a physical Target store. If you live somewhere without a nearby Target, Walmart, or dense delivery network, Prime’s broader logistics infrastructure is likely to remain the more reliable option regardless of price.
How These Memberships Handle Price Matching and Deals
None of these five programs offer formal price matching against each other or against non-member competitors, but each runs its own version of member-exclusive deal events. Prime Day and its accompanying Prime Big Deal Days remain the largest and most heavily promoted of these events, followed by Walmart’s own deal days timed to compete directly during the same shopping windows.
Target Circle 360 members get early access to Target Circle Week deals, while Costco and Sam’s Club run periodic member-only coupon books rather than flash sale events, reflecting their generally slower-moving, bulk-purchase shopping model compared to the faster promotional cadence of Prime, Walmart+, and Target Circle 360.
Mobile App Quality Across the Five Options
App quality varies more than people expect between these five memberships. Amazon’s shopping app remains the most feature-rich, with AI-assisted deal finding, extensive price history tracking, and tight integration across Prime Video, Music, and Grubhub+ within a single login. Walmart’s app has closed much of that gap in recent years, particularly around in-store navigation and Scan & Go checkout.
Target’s app handles same-day delivery and in-store pickup smoothly but offers a narrower feature set overall, while Costco and Sam’s Club apps are more utilitarian, focused on digital membership cards, receipts, and basic online ordering rather than a full ecommerce experience comparable to Amazon or Walmart.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Walmart+ actually cheaper than Amazon Prime?
Yes, Walmart+ costs $98 a year compared to Prime’s $139, though the two memberships emphasize different benefits, grocery delivery and gas savings versus broad ecommerce shipping and entertainment.
Can I use Costco or Sam’s Club instead of Amazon Prime?
Not as a direct replacement. Warehouse memberships save money on bulk household goods but don’t offer fast shipping on a broad catalog or any entertainment perks the way Prime does.
Does Target Circle 360 include free shipping like Prime?
Yes, Target Circle 360 includes free two-day shipping and free same-day delivery on eligible orders, though it’s limited to Target’s catalog rather than a marketplace as broad as Amazon’s.
Is it worth having both Amazon Prime and a warehouse club membership?
For many households, yes, since the two serve different purposes: Prime for fast shipping and entertainment, warehouse clubs for bulk grocery and household savings.
Which Prime alternative has the best free trial?
Walmart+ offers a 30-day trial for $1, while Target Circle 360 and the warehouse clubs typically offer shorter promotional trial periods that are worth checking before committing to an annual plan.
Do any of these alternatives offer a student discount like Amazon Prime?
Yes, both Walmart+ and Target Circle 360 offer discounted rates for verified students, similar to Amazon’s own Prime Student pricing, and it’s worth checking eligibility on each provider’s site since the specific discount percentage changes periodically.
Which of these memberships is best if I run an online store?
Amazon Prime remains the most useful for ecommerce operators specifically, since its broad catalog and fast shipping make it the best tool for competitor research and product testing, though a warehouse club membership is worth adding separately if you also buy packaging or supplies in bulk.
Ready to build a business that doesn’t depend on any single membership or platform? See how our done-for-you store builds work →
Disclaimer
This article is for informational purposes only. Membership pricing and benefits for Amazon Prime, Walmart+, Costco, Sam’s Club, and Target Circle 360 change periodically. Always verify current pricing directly on each provider’s website before subscribing. Ecommerce Paradise uses affiliate links for some providers mentioned in this article, which does not affect the recommendations made here.
Trevor Fenner is an ecommerce entrepreneur and the founder of Ecommerce Paradise, a platform focused on helping entrepreneurs build and scale profitable high-ticket ecommerce and dropshipping businesses. With over a decade of hands-on experience, Trevor specializes in high-ticket dropshipping strategy, niche and product selection, supplier recruiting and onboarding, Google & Bing Shopping ads, ecommerce SEO, and systems-driven automation and scaling. Through Ecommerce Paradise, he provides free education via in-depth guides like How to Start High-Ticket Dropshipping, advanced training through the High-Ticket Dropshipping Masterclass, and fully done-for-you turnkey ecommerce services for entrepreneurs who want a faster, more hands-off path to growth. Trevor is known for emphasizing sustainable, real-world ecommerce models over hype-driven tactics, helping store owners build scalable, sellable, and location-independent brands.
Still deciding what to sell?
Grab the free list of 1,000+ niches that work for high-ticket dropshipping, sorted by category.
Free. Unsubscribe any time.
